Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara Review: Drama Lashes That Refuse To Budge

Yes. In our wear tests, the hourglass brush and thick, film-forming formula created noticeably fuller, longer lashes even on thin or short lash lines. One coat gave defined, everyday drama, while a second carefully applied coat pushed the effect toward a plush, false-lash look.

It held up impressively through crying, humidity, and light-to-moderate swimming without obvious streaks or flaking. During prolonged submersion or if you rub your eyes, you may see some subtle transfer, but compared to standard mascaras it remains one of the most tenacious we’ve worn.

On normal-to-dry lids, we saw very little flaking or smudging, even after long days. On very oily lids or over rich eye creams, some testers did notice under-eye shadows or transfer by late afternoon. Setting the under-eye area with powder and letting the mascara fully dry helped reduce this significantly.

Yes. Several of our testers with sparse, post-extension, or mature lashes saw some of the biggest transformations. The hourglass brush can grab tiny hairs, and the volumizing formula builds density along the lash line, making lashes appear thicker and more lifted when applied in thin, controlled coats.

Both versions deliver bold volume and length, but the waterproof formula feels thicker, sets more firmly, and is far more resistant to water and humidity. It also tends to be less flaky than the original, though it can feel clumpier and is significantly harder to remove, so it’s best reserved for days you truly need waterproof wear.

Volume and waterproofing come from a blend of VP/Eicosene Copolymer, water-resistant polymers, and waxes like paraffin, beeswax, and carnauba. These create a flexible film around each lash, building thickness while locking pigment in place against moisture, sweat, and tears.

Yes. The formula includes Porcelain Flower (Hoya Lacunosa) extract and omega-rich Plukenetia Volubilis Seed Oil, which help moisturize and condition lashes. In our testing, lashes didn’t feel unusually brittle after wear when we removed the product gently with an appropriate remover.

The brand is cruelty-free and does not test on animals, but the formula is not vegan. It contains beeswax, an animal-derived ingredient, along with other waxes and conditioning agents that contribute to its volumizing, waterproof texture.

It’s formulated for the eye area, but it is an intense, waterproof formula. Some of our more sensitive testers and contact lens wearers experienced redness, itching, or irritation and had to discontinue. If your eyes are reactive, patch test carefully and stop use at the first sign of discomfort.

The ingredient list does not show traditional parabens or sulfates. It does include Phenoxyethanol as a preservative and Cyclopentasiloxane, a silicone that helps the formula glide smoothly and enhances water resistance. If you avoid silicones, this is important to note.

Start by curling your lashes. Wipe excess product from the wand, then press it into the roots and wiggle upward in one smooth motion. Work in thin coats, allowing the first to become slightly tacky before adding a second. Using a clean lash comb while it’s still soft can perfect separation.

We recommend curling before application, as the waterproof formula sets quickly and will lock in that shape. A lash primer designed for waterproof formulas can boost volume and separation further, especially if your natural lashes are very straight or sparse.

Yes, but use a delicate touch. We had the best results using just the tapered tip of the brush, or a separate skinny wand, to lightly coat lower lashes. This minimizes specks and helps prevent the under-eye area from looking heavy or smudged by day’s end.

With daily use and careful brush cleaning, a tube typically performs well for a few months before the texture becomes noticeably drier or clumpier. As with most waterproof mascaras, keeping the cap tightly closed and avoiding pumping the wand helps prolong its usable life.

You can, but we found it performs best either alone or over a dedicated lash primer. Layering it over another full mascara can quickly become heavy and clumpy due to its thick, waterproof texture. If you do layer, keep the base coat light and let it dry down slightly first.

Use an oil-based or dual-phase waterproof eye makeup remover. Saturate a cotton pad, press gently over closed eyes for several seconds to dissolve the film, then slide downward along the lashes. Avoid rubbing back and forth; patience and soaking are key to protecting your lash line.

Yes, significantly. Its high-performance waterproof polymers cling tightly to lashes, so standard cleansers and water won’t fully break it down. Without a proper remover and soak-and-slide technique, removal can feel frustrating and may tug at lashes, which is why we reserve it for days we truly need waterproof wear.

On its own, the formula includes conditioning ingredients and doesn’t inherently break lashes. However, daily use combined with rushed or aggressive removal can lead to shedding or breakage. If you wear it often, be meticulous with gentle removal and consider giving lashes an occasional break with a softer, non-waterproof formula.

Once set, lashes feel firm and held in place but not painfully stiff. You can feel that a waterproof film is present, especially with multiple coats, yet our testers didn’t describe it as uncomfortably crunchy. If you prefer a barely-there feel, though, you may find this more structured than you like.

Rinse immediately with plenty of clean water, blinking gently to help flush the product out. Avoid rubbing your eyes. If irritation, redness, or a filmy sensation persists after rinsing, seek medical advice, especially if you wear contact lenses or have a history of eye sensitivity.

The formula is intentionally thick and fast-setting to deliver dramatic volume and waterproof wear, which means it can clump or feel dry if you overload the brush, apply too many coats, or if the tube is not tightly sealed. Cleaning the brush periodically and working in thin layers helps maintain a smoother application.

For most of our testers, it resisted smudging remarkably well, even through long days and humidity. However, those with very oily lids, heavy eye creams, or hooded eyes sometimes saw transfer to the under-eye area or brow bone. Strategic powdering and allowing full dry-down can improve results, but it’s not universally flawless.

You’re paying for a prestige formula that marries dramatic volume with serious waterproofing. For special occasions and high-stakes wear, the investment feels justified. If you rarely need waterproof performance or are satisfied with softer, more everyday lashes, less expensive mascaras may meet your needs just as well.

Absolutely. This is where it shines. We reached for it consistently for weddings, beach trips, pool days, and overnight events because it stayed put through sweat, tears, and humidity. Pack it with a travel-sized waterproof remover so you can take it off properly at the end of the night.

The mascara comes in the brand’s signature sleek tube with the iconic hourglass brush inside. The component feels weighty and substantial in the hand, and the screw-top closure gives a reassuring twist-and-click sensation that helps keep the formula sealed between uses.