Eyes & Mascara Reviews

Tarte’s Tartelette Tubing Mascara is a study in modern lash luxury: clean, inky definition with a surprisingly gentle exit strategy. In our testing, it excelled at turning short, pale, or sparse lashes into something that genuinely reads as present—lengthened, darkened, and fanned out, without the weight of a traditional drama mascara. The tubing technology shines at night, when those little sleeves slip off under warm water and you realize you haven’t sacrificed a single lash to your makeup remover.

This is not a flawless icon: flaking and curl drop are real considerations for certain eye shapes, skin types, and lash textures. But for many of us, it quietly replaced both our everyday mascara and our “special occasion” one, because it threads that rare needle between impact and effortlessness. If you’re willing to learn its rhythm—quick coats, minimal fuss—it can absolutely earn a permanent place in your makeup bag.

Monsieur Big is the mascara equivalent of a little black dress with a plunging neckline: undeniably flattering, slightly high-maintenance, and designed to be seen. In our testing, it delivered the kind of plush, inky volume that makes even mascara minimalists do a double-take in the mirror. Sparse, aging, or naturally fair lashes in particular looked suddenly present—thicker, longer, and more defined without the faff of strip lashes.

This is not, however, a low-effort, low-risk formula. The generous brush and thick texture demand a mindful hand to avoid clumps and smudges, and those with oily lids or sensitive eyes may find its limits sooner than they’d like. When paired with good technique and a proper remover, it behaves like a true prestige staple; when rushed, it can feel like an indulgence that doesn’t quite earn its keep. For the right lash personality—bold, dramatic, unafraid of a little ritual—Monsieur Big is a lavish companion. For others, it’s a beautiful occasional piece rather than an everyday uniform.

IT Cosmetics Superhero Mascara is a study in high drama with high maintenance. In our testing, it delivered some of the most striking length and depth we’ve seen from a non-tubing formula—especially on short, fine, or mature lashes that usually resist transformation. The inky pigment, elastic-stretch polymers, and skincare-inspired actives work together to create a plush, almost lash-extension effect.

But this isn’t a lazy-girl mascara. The formula loads heavily on the wand, demands a wiped brush and thin coats, and tends to thicken in the tube faster than we’d like. Wear is beautiful on many lids, yet temperamental in humidity or on very oily skin, where flaking and smudging can creep in. If you relish a little artistry at your vanity and crave bold, editorial lashes, this is a luxurious ally. If you want effortless, no-thought application and perfect value per drop, there are more forgiving options.

Lancôme Définicils is the mascara we reach for when we want our lashes to look like they simply woke up perfect. It doesn’t shout, it doesn’t clump, it doesn’t flake — it just quietly lengthens and defines, creating that impossibly natural lash line that reads as good genetics rather than good makeup. In our testing, it excelled on fine, sparse, and mature lashes that tend to look spidery with volumizing formulas, and it remained comfortable on even the fussiest, most sensitive eyes. The caveat: performance is only as good as the freshness of the tube, and some online stock felt older and drier than what we’re used to from the counter. If you’re willing to source it carefully and you crave a clean, classic lash rather than a dramatic one, Définicils earns its cult status as a quiet-luxury staple.

Maneater is Tarte’s answer to the “are those your real lashes?” question — and in our testing, it often earned that double-take. The inky cream formula, paired with a 500+ bristle hourglass brush, builds plush volume and elegant length with a feline, lifted effect that flatters almost every eye shape. We loved how soft and flexible lashes felt, even with multiple coats, and how kind the formula was to sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. This is not a waterproof warrior, and oily lids or humid climates can coax out smudging, especially on the lower lash line. But if you’re chasing dramatic, separated lashes with a prestige-feeling application ritual, Maneater is a lavish, high-performing choice — with a few smart precautions, it can be a true everyday indulgence.